Write your message
Volume 19, Issue 41 (12-2023)                   Marine Engineering 2023, 19(41): 42-58 | Back to browse issues page

XML Persian Abstract Print


Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:

Edalatfar I, shojapoorian S. Providing solutionto teduce the responsibilities of the maritime transport operator in the faceof the evidens of fault. Marine Engineering 2023; 19 (41) :42-58
URL: http://marine-eng.ir/article-1-1068-en.html
1- former director of the legaland contracts departmentof the Genral Admynystrationof Ports and Maritime Affairs of Khozestan.lawyer and legal consultant
Abstract:   (377 Views)
Maritime transportation is one of the most important topics of maritime law, and in this topic, the most important category is the responsibility and exemption of the transport operator. The main purpose of this article is to present a solution to reduce the responsibility of the maritime transport operator in the face of the evidence of fault. The present research was carried out using a descriptive-analytical method. The method of collecting information is the library method and for collecting information laws, books, theses, theses, articles, databases (domestic and foreign) and other paper and digital sources have been used.
In this article, some key questions regarding the damage caused to the goods in sea transportation and the responsibility of the carrier have been examined. First, in case of cargo loss in sea transportation, who is responsible for compensation? Second, is the sea transport operator responsible for compensation? In this case, is his responsibility based on evidence of fault or presumption of fault? Thirdly, what are the cases of exemption of the sea transport operator, i.e. the exceptional cases in which the transport operator is exempt from responsibility? And what are the solutions to reduce the liability of the sea transport operator in the face of the presumption of fault?
In order to answer the mentioned questions, while stating the definitions and basics of the carrier's responsibilities and exemptions, he examined and explained the basics of the carrier's responsibility in the international conventions governing the maritime transportation of goods, civil rights, trade laws, and maritime laws of Iran. and the responsibilities and exemptions of the sea transport operator have been stated. In the end, it was concluded that regardless of the basis and nature of the responsibility of the maritime transport operator, he can be exempted from the responsibility by referring to some exemptions that are mentioned in international conventions and regulations and domestic laws. be freed In this context, solutions have been presented to reduce the responsibility of the sea transport operator in the face of the evidence of fault.
Key words: 
transportation, maritime transportation, responsibility of the maritime transportation operator, cases of exemption and limitation of the responsibility of the maritime transportation operator, proof of fault
Full-Text [PDF 1480 kb]   (47 Downloads)    
Type of Study: Research Paper | Subject: Environmental Study
Received: 2023/10/28 | Accepted: 2023/12/31

References
1. Iwami, Hardy. (1384) Maritime Law. Translated by Mansour Pournouri، Tehran: Second Edition، Mahd-e Haqqat Publications(In Persian)
2. The Child, Abraham. (1401). Maritime Transport Law An Analytical Study of the Responsibility of Maritime Transport Operator in Iranian Law, Islamic Law and the 1924 Brussels Conventions 1978 Hamburg 2008 and Rotterdam. New Edition, Tehran: Majmaj Elmi and Cultural Publications, 5th Edition (reprint) (In Persian)
3. Katusian, Nasser. (1374). Outside contractual obligations, coercive guarantees. Volume 1. University of Tehran Press: First edition(In Persian)
4. Aghayi. Sarah, Saheb, Tayyebeh. (1400) The effects of unjustified deviation from the path on the responsibility of the carrier of goods: A comparative review of Iran's and the 2009 Rotterdam Convention. Comparative Law Research.25(4):47-67. (In Persian)
5. Amini, Eisa. (1389). Liability association of the operator of the transportation of goods with the guilt guarantee of the owner of the goods. Judicial Law Journal of the Ministry of Justice No. 33(In Persian)
6. Bozorgmehr,AmirAbbas,Sobati,Lida,Madanian,Iman, (1398). Legal System Governing the Exemption of Maritime Transport Operator from Civil Liability. Judicial Law Journal, 26(26), 49-68. (In Persian)
7. Parvar,Maryam and Associates. (1400). Investigating and analyzing the role of maritime transportation sector on economic growth in Khuzestan province. Journal of Transportation Research, 18(4), 85-98(In Persian)
8. Taghi Zadeh, Abraham. (1389). Comparative and analytical study of the basis of responsibility of the transport operator of domestic law with the responsibility of the rail transport operator based on the Kotiev Convention. Journal of Transportation Research. Number 1(In Persian)
9. Taghi Zadeh,Ebrahim,Ahmadi,Afshin. (1394). Comparative study of the limits and bases of liability of the maritime carrier in the Rotterdam Convention with the Conventions of Brussels and Hamburg. Comparative Law Magazine, Issue 2(In Persian)
10. Javan Bakht, Mohammad, Sadeghian Lemrasaki, Mohadeseh. (1401). Exemption of maritime transport operator from civil liability in Iranian law and international regulations. No. 50, Autumn 1401, Maritime Security Police, Tehran, Iran (In Persian)
11. Kamel,Hamid. (1399). Characteristics and legal nature of the contract for transportation of goods with respect to the rights and duties of the transport operator from the perspective of civil law and commercial law. New Journal of Jurisprudence and Law, (3)1(In Persian)
12. Hamid, Kamel, Safari, Sajjad. (1401). Exemption cases of maritime transport operators from civil liability in Iran's legal system and international law. International Conference on Jurisprudence, Law and Religious Research(In Persian)
13. Abdu'llahi,Saad-o-Allah. (1389). Translation of Rotterdam Convention, Tehran Port Affairs and Special Zones of Ports and Maritime Organization, 1389, p. 8-10(In Persian)
14. Mahbubi, Mansour. (1395). International Banking and Transportation of Goods. Transportation Industry, Vol. 23, Third Edition, Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs Publications (In Persian)
15. Mohammadzadeh Vadeghani, Alireza ,Kardan, Katayoun (1391). Translation of Rotterdam Convention, Law Quarterly, Journal of Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, No. 1(In Persian)
16. Mohebi, Mehrasa. (1392). Comparative Study of the Liability of Transportation Operator for Damage to Goods in Hamburg and Rotterdam Conventions. Legal Research, Fall & Winter 1392 - Number 24(In Persian)
17. Malek, Hadi, Namdar, Shokouh Vatabai, Mahshid-o-sadat. (1401). Check the responsibility of the transport operator in customs affairs. Tehran, Journal of Contemporary Research in Management and Accounting Sciences, 4th Year, No. 14, 54-59(In Persian)
18. Yazdanian,Alireza. (1390). Principles of Operator's Civil Liability in Commodity Transport Contracts in Iranian and French Law. Judicial Law Journal, Spring 90, Issue 73(In Persian)
19. Ahmadi, Afshin. (1392). Limits of Liability for Maritime Transport Operator and Exemption Cases Based on Rotterdam Convention 2009. Master of Science in Private Law, Payame Noor University, Central Tehran. (In Persian)
20. Demirchili, Mohammed. (1383). Civil Liability of Maritime Transport Operator: A Comparative Study on British Iranian Law and the Hamburg Convention. Ph.D. Dissertation of Private Law, University of Tehran. (In Persian)
21. Saeedi, Tahereh (1391) Comparative study of duties and responsibilities of the transport operator based on the Rotterdam conventions and "Hamburg Master thesis in international law Islamic Azad University Central Tehran Branch(In Persian).
22. Samadi Ahari, Mohammad Hashem. (1370). Civil responsibility of maritime transport operator, Master thesis, Azad University Law School(In Persian).
23. Kardan, Katayoun. (1390). The duties and obligations of the sender of goods in the Hamburg and Rotterdam Conventions. Master of Science in International Law, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch. (In Persian)
24. Mohebi, Mehrasa. (1389). Comparative study of the responsibility of the carrier of maritime carriage for damage of goods in the Hamburg and Rotterdam Conventions. Master of Science in International Law, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran. (In Persian)
25. Mehran, Farhad. (1373).Responsible for maritime transportation of goods in Iranian law. Thesis, University of Tehran, p. 66. (In Persian)
26. Vahed Zadeh, Mosa. (1381). Maritime transport operator relying on judicial procedure. M.Sc. Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Central Tehran Branch. (In Persian)
27. Hashemizadeh, Seyed Ali Reza. (1378A). The responsibility of the shippers for goods according to the Conventions of Brussels 1924 and Hamburg 1978. Master of Private Law, Imam Sadiq University. (In Persian)
28. Adamsson, Joakim, The Rotterdam Rules, A Transport Convention for The Future? Faculty of Law Lund University, Autumn semester 2011
29. Berlingieri, Francesco, An Analysis Of Two Recent Commentaries Of The Rotterdam Rules, Il Diritto Marittimo: Qarterly Journal of Italian and Foreign Doctrin Jurisprudence and Legislation, Roma, Fasc. I - 2012, P: 21
30. Christian von Bar and Mult Ulrich Drobnig. The interaction of Contract Law and Tort and Property law in Europe, SELLIER. European Law PUBLISHERS, First Ed, Hamburg, 1998 pp16
31. Economic Commission for Europe, Inland transport Committee, possibilities for reconciliation and harmonization of civil liability regimes governing combined transport, 1998.pp20
32. Isaacs, Marc D, Cofman, Alan S, The Rotterdam Rules & "Wet" Multimodal Shipping: Important Concepts for Lawyers, [on line]. Available: http://www.cmla.org/...The%20Rotterdam%20Rules...20Isaacs.Cofman.pdf Visited on: 2013/06/11
33. Neels, R, The Rotterdam Rules and Modern Transport Practices: A Successful Marriage? Iijdschrift Vervoer é- Recht, 2011-1, [on line]. Available: http://www.rotterdamrules.com/sites/default/.../pdf/20marriage.pdf. Visited on: 2013/05/1

Send email to the article author


Rights and permissions
Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Creative Commons License
International Journal of Maritime Technology is licensed under a

Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.